Comparing the two
| Criterion | UV system | Continuous chlorination |
|---|---|---|
| Taste and odour | No change | Possible chlorine taste |
| Residual disinfectant | No | Yes, in the plumbing |
| Giardia and Cryptosporidium | Effective | Cryptosporidium resists chlorine |
| Iron and sulfur | Must be treated first | Oxidized by chlorine, then filtered |
| Maintenance | Yearly lamp, clean sleeve | Chemical, metering pump, residual checks |
When chlorination makes sense
Water heavy in iron, sulfur or iron bacteria can justify chlorination followed by filtration. See continuous chlorination.
Shock chlorination: a one-time fix
Shock chlorination disinfects the well after work or a positive test. It doesn't replace continuous disinfection. See well shock chlorination.
Frequently asked questions
Does UV replace all filters?
No. It targets microorganisms, not hardness or chemical contaminants. Pre-treatment is often needed.
Can I copy a chlorine dose I found online?
No. Dosing depends on the water and the system, so it has to be set and checked.
What certification should a UV system have?
NSF/ANSI 55, with the model chosen for your water and flow.
Sources and references
- Water treatment · Health Canada
- Enteric protozoa: Giardia and Cryptosporidium · Health Canada
- Ultraviolet Technical Fact Sheet · Water Quality Association
- Treat your well water · Health Canada