Three checks to find the cause
| What you notice | Likely cause | Next step |
|---|---|---|
| Smell in hot water only | Reaction in the water heater (anode) | Water heater diagnosis by a professional |
| Smell in hot and cold water | Hydrogen sulfide in the well | Treatment where water enters the house |
| Smell at one sink only | Drain or trap, not the water | Clean the drain |
How to do the test
Fill a glass of cold water away from the sink, then a glass of hot water, at two or three taps. Smell them in another room: you'll know whether the smell comes from the water or the drain.
Why the smell is worse in the morning
Water sits overnight in the pipes and water heater; the gas builds up and is released at the first draw.
When the smell is in the hot water
According to the Water Quality Association, a harmless bacterium can react with the water heater's magnesium anode. Replacing the anode or adjusting the temperature is a job for a qualified professional. See water heaters and stagnation.
When the smell comes from the well
Hydrogen sulfide is measured on site, because it escapes quickly from a sample. Treatment depends on the level, pH and iron.
Treatment options
- aeration and degassing;
- air injection or chemical oxidation, then filtration: often combined with iron and manganese (iron and manganese filter);
- catalytic carbon for a faint smell.
Frequently asked questions
Is rotten-egg smelling water dangerous?
Health Canada's objective for hydrogen sulfide (0.05 mg/L) is aesthetic. The smell says nothing about bacteria, so a well still needs regular testing.
Will shock chlorination fix the smell?
It can temporarily reduce sulfur bacteria in the well. If the gas occurs naturally in the groundwater, the smell returns: continuous treatment is the lasting fix.
Will a water softener remove the smell?
Not reliably; it targets hardness. Hydrogen sulfide needs oxidation or catalytic carbon.
Sources and references
- Guidelines for Canadian Drinking Water Quality: Operational Parameters · Health Canada
- Bad Taste & Smell · Water Quality Association
- Treat your well water · Health Canada